Blog Post

The Pros and Cons of Conducting Your Own Asbestos Survey

Adam Fox • 15 June 2023

Asbestos surveys are essential to identify the presence, location, and condition of ACMs, which helps in managing and controlling the risks associated with asbestos exposure

Asbestos is a hazardous material that was commonly used in buildings before its ban in 1999. Asbestos-containing materials (ACMs) can be found in many buildings constructed before the ban, including offices, schools, hospitals, and homes. Asbestos surveys are essential to identify the presence, location, and condition of ACMs, which helps in managing and controlling the risks associated with asbestos exposure. In this article, I will discuss the pros and cons of conducting your own asbestos survey.


Introduction to Asbestos Surveys


An asbestos survey is a systematic examination of a building to identify the presence and condition of ACMs. The survey should be conducted by a competent person who has the necessary training, knowledge, and experience to identify and assess the risks associated with asbestos. The purpose of the survey is to provide information on the location, type, and condition of ACMs, which is then used to develop an asbestos management plan.


Understanding the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012


The Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 (CAR2012) is the primary legislation that governs the management of asbestos in the UK. The regulations require duty holders to identify the presence of ACMs in their building and assess the risks associated with them. Duty holders must also develop an asbestos management plan and take steps to manage and control the risks associated with asbestos exposure.


What is HSG264?


HSG264 is the Health and Safety Executive’s (HSE) guidance document on managing asbestos in non-domestic premises. The guidance provides practical advice on how to comply with CAR2012, including how to conduct an asbestos survey. HSG264 recommends that asbestos surveys should be conducted by a competent person who has the necessary training, knowledge, and experience to identify and assess the risks associated with asbestos.


Ways to Demonstrate Competence for Conducting Asbestos Survey


There are several ways to demonstrate competence for conducting asbestos surveys. One way is to hold a BOHS P402 or equivalent qualification, which demonstrates that the individual has the necessary knowledge and skills to conduct asbestos surveys. Another way is to have relevant experience and training in asbestos surveying and management. It is essential to ensure that the person conducting the survey is competent and has the necessary skills and experience to identify and assess the risks associated with asbestos.


Understanding the Role of P402 or Equivalent in Asbestos Management


The BOHS P402 or equivalent qualification is a standard requirement for asbestos surveyors. The qualification demonstrates that the individual has the necessary knowledge and skills to conduct asbestos surveys and manage the risks associated with asbestos. The P402 or equivalent qualification is recognised by the HSE as evidence of competence for conducting asbestos surveys.


Types of Asbestos Surveys


There are two types of asbestos surveys: management surveys and refurbishment and demolition surveys. A management survey is conducted to identify the presence, location, and condition of ACMs that may be disturbed during normal occupancy and maintenance of a building. A refurbishment and demolition survey is conducted to identify the presence, location, and condition of ACMs that may be disturbed during refurbishment or demolition of a building.


Pros of Conducting Your Own Asbestos Survey


Conducting your own asbestos survey can save you money and provide you with a better understanding of the risks associated with asbestos in your building. It can also be more convenient, as you can schedule the survey at a time that suits you. If you have the necessary qualification, skills and experience to conduct an asbestos survey, it can be a viable option.


Cons of Conducting Your Own Asbestos Survey


Conducting your own asbestos survey can be risky if you do not have the necessary skills and experience. It can also be time-consuming and may not be as cost-effective as it first seems if you have to purchase equipment and materials. If the survey is not conducted correctly, it may not identify all the ACMs in your building, which can lead to significant health and safety risks and potential prosecution.


Choosing the Right Asbestos Surveyor - P402 or Equivalent


Choosing the right asbestos surveyor is essential to ensure that your survey is conducted correctly and that all ACMs are identified. Look for a surveyor who holds a BOHS P402 or equivalent qualification and has relevant experience and training in asbestos surveying and management. It is also essential to check that the surveyor has adequate insurance and is a member of a professional body.


The Importance of Following the Asbestos Management Plan


Following the asbestos management plan is crucial to managing and controlling the risks associated with asbestos. The plan should include information on the location, type, and condition of ACMs, as well as procedures for managing and controlling the risks associated with asbestos exposure. It is essential to ensure that all staff and contractors are aware of the plan and comply with its requirements.


The Benefits of Hiring a Professional Consultancy like Consulo Compliance


Hiring a professional consultancy like Consulo Compliance can provide you with peace of mind that your asbestos survey is conducted correctly and that all ACMs are identified. Consulo Compliance has a team of experienced and qualified asbestos consultants who hold the BOHS P402 or equivalent qualifications. We also have the necessary insurance and are members of professional bodies, ensuring that our work is of the highest quality.


The Role of Consulo Compliance in Asbestos Surveys


Consulo Compliance provides a range of asbestos-related services, including surveys, management plans, and training. We use the latest equipment and techniques to identify and assess the risks associated with asbestos, ensuring that our clients are compliant with CAR2012. Consulo Compliance also provides ongoing support and advice to ensure that their clients remain compliant with asbestos regulations.


Conclusion


Conducting your own asbestos survey can be a viable option if you have the necessary skills and experience. However, it can be risky if you do not have the necessary training and knowledge. Hiring a professional consultancy like Consulo Compliance can provide you with peace of mind that your survey is conducted correctly and that all ACMs are identified. Contact Consulo Compliance today to ensure you are and remain compliant with CAR2012.

Contact Us Today
by Adam Fox 9 April 2025
Asbestos and the Circular Economy: Why It's Time to Stop Burying the Problem Twenty-five years after asbestos was banned in the UK, we’re still digging a hole—literally and metaphorically. Every day, across the country, asbestos waste is double-bagged, labelled, loaded into skips, and driven to landfill, where it will sit indefinitely, taking up valuable space, creating ongoing liability, and adding to our already bloated environmental burden. And yet, 2025 presents a different path. A smarter one. One that replaces disposal with repurposing, and turns a dangerous waste product into a useful, circular resource. The technology exists. So the question we should be asking isn’t “Can we recycle asbestos?” It’s “Why the hell aren’t we doing it already?” Landfill is Failing Us—But We’re Still Relying On It Let’s start with the basics. There are still over 1.5 million buildings in the UK that contain asbestos, most of them now approaching the end of their useful life. As these structures age or undergo refurbishment, the volume of asbestos waste is only going to increase. Right now, we handle that waste the same way we did decades ago: • Identify it • Remove it (usually under fully controlled conditions) • Seal it in heavy-duty plastic • Drive it to landfill • Bury it • Forget about it Except we don’t forget, do we? Because landfill space is running out. Disposal costs are going up. And the environmental cost? We’re only just starting to count it. There’s a Better Way—and It Already Works Here’s what most duty holders don’t realise: We no longer have to bury asbestos. Thanks to recent advances in thermal treatment technology, we now have a method that can safely denature asbestos, breaking down its fibrous structure and rendering it harmless. Companies like Thermal Recycling in the UK are already proving this is not science fiction. They’re using high temperatures to transform asbestos cement products—like corrugated roofing sheets—into an inert ceramic material that’s completely safe. But here's the best bit: That material isn’t just neutral. It’s useful. It can be crushed and graded into aggregate, which can be used in road construction, paving, and concrete mixes. Instead of creating a waste burden for the next generation, we’re creating a valuable, low-carbon building material. Why Aggregate Matters in the Carbon Equation The production of virgin aggregates—through mining and quarrying—is energy-intensive and environmentally damaging. It contributes significantly to CO₂ emissions and destroys natural landscapes. So by replacing some of that demand with recycled aggregate from denatured asbestos, we: • Cut carbon emissions • Reduce dependence on extraction • Shrink the environmental footprint of infrastructure projects • Extend the life of quarries and reduce waste tonnage That’s not just a win for waste management. That’s a win for the entire construction supply chain. And yet most people in the industry don’t even know it’s possible. Why Are We Still Burying What Could Be Reused? As someone who’s worked in asbestos compliance for over 20 years—and now helps business leaders manage risk more intelligently—I’ve seen the same patterns play out time and time again: • “We’ll just do what we’ve always done.” • “This project’s tight on budget—landfill’s cheaper, right?” • “We’re just following the usual route—it’s less risky.” Let’s be honest. That mindset is outdated, short-sighted, and lazy. Cost may always be a factor, but the belief that landfill is “cheaper” needs to be challenged. Once you factor in: • Long-term environmental costs • Reputational risk • Rising disposal fees • And the public pressure for sustainable practices Thermal recycling is already starting to make sense. Especially when the output is something usable, not something buried. Licensed Contractors: You Don’t Get a Free Pass Either This isn’t just about clients or duty holders. Licensed Asbestos Removal Contractors (LARC’s) have a moral obligation here too. And I say that not from a place of opinion—but from first-hand experience, day in and day out for over two decades. Too often, LARCs put profits over progress. They default to landfill because it’s faster, easier to price up, and keeps their margins clean. They know the alternatives exist—but they don’t explore them, let alone offer them to their clients. When you hold a licence from the HSE, you’re not just a business—you’re a guardian of public health. That comes with responsibility. Choosing the most sustainable, forward-thinking disposal route should be part of that. Especially when the technology is available, proven, and legal. It’s time for the industry to stop hiding behind what’s convenient and start leading from the front. A Moral Obligation for Everyone Involved Whether you’re a: • Local authority managing public buildings • Developer under pressure to go green • Commercial landlord looking to reduce liability • Or a licensed contractor with influence over disposal routes —you have a responsibility to look beyond the cheapest or fastest option. If there’s a proven, safe, and more sustainable way to manage asbestos, you have a duty to understand it before choosing to ignore it. Because let’s be honest: “We didn’t know” isn’t going to wash when the public starts asking why we’re still filling landfill sites with a problem we already have the technology to eliminate. So What Can You Do Differently? No one’s asking you to overhaul your entire waste strategy overnight. But you can—and should—start asking better questions: • “Is landfill our only option here?” • “Could this waste stream be recycled instead of buried?” • “What suppliers, contractors, or experts do we know who can help us explore this?” You don’t have to be a global pioneer. But if you’re in a position of responsibility, you should at least be aware that the old way isn’t the only way anymore. Final Thought: The Future Is Circular—Whether You Join In or Not Asbestos will be with us for decades to come. That’s a fact. But how we handle it—and whether we choose to keep repeating the past or do something smarter—is up to us. Thermal recycling and other denaturing technologies offer a rare opportunity to do something that actually moves the industry forward. Not just ticking the compliance box. Not just burying the problem. But solving it—and turning it into something useful in the process. If you’re involved in asbestos management in even the slightest way, ask yourself this: Are you part of the problem, or part of the solution?
by Adam Fox 13 January 2025
Compliance is no longer just about avoiding fines; it’s about creating workplaces where people can thrive.
by Adam Fox 6 December 2024
This is more than a regulatory issue—it’s a moral obligation
by Adam Fox 7 November 2024
Elevating health and safety from a compliance obligation to a strategic business focus offers immense benefits
by Adam Fox 4 September 2024
A groundbreaking solution to a long-standing problem
by Adam Fox 21 August 2024
More companies, sole traders and responsible individuals are now facing hefty fines or even custodial sentences for non-compliance
Show More
Share by: